American Pie Company

29 Route 37 (center junction of Routes 37 and 39) Sherman, CT 06784
Restaurant's Website
Customer Reviews

NER Notes

Great breakfast spot, famous for their potato pancakes and spiced apples. Mix of American and German-inspired fare. The attached bakery makes some of the best pie you will have anywhere.


Rated by Riders

One review per rider. Learn more about Rider Reviews and Ratings

You must Log In to leave a review. Read about NER User Accounts before attempting to register.

Average Rider Rating
  • Food

    5.005 (1 Review)
  • Service

    3.005 (1 Review)
  • Ambiance/View

    3.005 (1 Review)
  • MC Parking

    4.005 (1 Review)
  • MC Attire Appropriate

    4.005 (1 Review)

  • American Pie Company

    Jan 17, 2022

    • Food

    • Service

    • Ambiance/View

    • MC Parking

    • MC Attire Appropriate


    Made this a destination for a late breakfast during the Housatonic Valley Ride and was not disappointed. The breakfast food was great, but the top food mark is for the strawberry rhubarb pie that I picked up to take home. Best pie I've eaten to-date.